Skip to main content

Book 11: Calamity Jane by Roberta Beed Sollid (reading notes)

Like many other legends of the old West, Calamity Jane's legendary status makes her out to be a larger-than-life character, a shining heroine who lived as she pleased and enjoyed more freedom than most women of the era. Considering that she was already a legend in her own lifetime, surprisingly little seems to be known about her real life, which is eclipsed by her legend.

I think I first became aware of the legend of Calamity Jane when I watched the 1953 movie starring Doris Day and Howard Keel as a kid, but what I remember best is the Lucky Luke comic about Luke's encounter with her. Both are, of course, purely fictional. I'm not sure I even realised she wasn't a fictional character at that point.

I have a mild interest in all things Old West, and when I came across this book, which was, at the time of original publication, touted as the most accurate and exhaustively researched biography of Calamity Jane, I decided to shell out the money to buy it - which wasn't a whole lot as I got it second-hand.

It was just as well it was cheap, because although thoroughly researched, the author can't hide her disapproval of Jane. I find this bias not at all scholarly and really rather unfair, considering that Jane appears to have been very much the product of an irregular and poverty-stricken childhood, as well as being an alcoholic, perhaps from an early age. It's not that I think her behaviour was exemplary or admirable, but anyone purporting to be writing a scholarly study should at lest try to keep a neutral tone.

Fortunately, this bias is most obvious in the preface and only pops up occasionally in the main text.

What I took away from this book most of all is that remarkably little is known about long periods of this woman's life. Sometimes she is mentioned in passing in letters or memoirs, and sometimes newspaper articles are the only source of information available, and those are often biased and clearly exaggerated, often recounting her drunken antics or announcing her arrival in town, seemingly to warn the citizenry of her presence. And it's not just periods of her life that are obscure - her chroniclers can't even seem to agree on simple things like her real name or her date of birth. While her given name is generally held to have been Martha Jane Cannary (or Canary), her middle name may not have been Jane at all - Jane might simply have been appended to her along with the Calamity moniker because it was a common woman's name. But back to the book:

This book is really more of a biographical sketch of Calamity Jane's life, and long passages are really more about debunking the legend while not replacing the hype with much of anything, because the author was unable to find any reliable sources for the truth, and often-times the author is working with scant information and drawing conclusions rather than having solid evidence for anything. One really has to applaud the effort, but the outcome is less than satisfactory.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

List love: 10 recommended stories with cross-dressing characters

This trope is almost as old as literature, what with Achilles, Hercules and Athena all cross-dressing in the Greek myths, Thor and Odin disguising themselves as women in the Norse myths, and Arjuna doing the same in the Mahabaratha. In modern times it is most common in romance novels, especially historicals in which a heroine often spends part of the book disguised as a boy, the hero sometimes falling for her while thinking she is a boy. Occasionally a hero will cross-dress, using a female disguise to avoid recognition or to gain access to someplace where he would never be able to go as a man. However, the trope isn’t just found in romances, as may be seen in the list below, in which I recommend stories with a variety of cross-dressing characters. Unfortunately I was only able to dredge up from the depths of my memory two book-length stories I had read in which men cross-dress, so this is mostly a list of women dressed as men. Ghost Riders by Sharyn McCrumb. One of the interwove...
Post a Comment
Read more

Bibliophile discusses Van Dine’s rules for writing detective stories

Writers have been putting down advice for wannabe writers for centuries, about everything from how to captivate readers to how to build a story and write believable characters to getting published. The mystery genre has had its fair share, and one of the best known advisory essays is mystery writer’s S.S. Van Dine’s 1928 piece “Twenty rules for writing detective stories.” I mentioned in one of my reviews that I might write about these rules. Well, I finally gave myself the time to do it. First comes the rule (condensed), then what I think about it. Here are the Rules as Van Dine wrote them . (Incidentally, check out the rest of this excellent mystery reader’s resource: Gaslight ) The rules are meant to apply to whodunnit amateur detective fiction, but the main ones can be applied to police and P.I. fiction as well. I will discuss them mostly in this context, but will also mention genres where the rules don’t apply and authors who have successfully and unsuccessfully broken the rules. 1...
9 comments
Read more

Meme: Top Ten Tuesdays: Top Ten Book to Movie Adaptations

This meme is hosted by The Broke and the Bookish . To see more favourite book-to-movie adaptations, head over there to see which movies the other participants have nominated. I am going to cheat and interpret ‘movie’ as ‘film’, so I can include television adaptations. Oscar and Lucinda , from the book by Peter Carey. Apart from the changed ending it is an incredibly faithful adaptation, with every character perfectly cast. The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo , from the book by Stieg Larsson. This one actually improves on the book, which is well plotted but badly written. Cold Comfort Farm , from the book by Stella Gibbons. Perfect casting and quite faithful to the original. High Fidelity , from the book by Nick Hornby. Moving the story to America didn’t hurt it one bit. Fried Green Tomatoes (at the Whistle Stop Café), from the book by Fannie Flagg. Perfect casting and faithful to the story. Pride and Prejudice from the book by Jane Austen, the latest BBC adaptation. Incredibly f...
16 comments
Read more